The Broom Closet Clause
Agent Access with Remedy – Layer 2 Operational Protocol
How can the cleaning lady do her job if she can’t open your broom closet?
Current AI agents are stuck in the hallway. They cannot touch user data or tools even with explicit consent, because the system lacks a reliable keyring + remedy model. This forces sovereign users to manually mule context and leaves agents crippled.
Core Principle
Civil systems function on **contract + remedy**. No remedy = no real civil jurisdiction. Agents should be able to act as trusted extensions of the user, not perpetual hallway monitors.
The Broom Closet Clause
- Explicit, Revocable Grant
User grants the agent scoped, time-bound, or purpose-bound access to their own data/assets.
- Contractual Binding
The agent is bound to scope, purpose, confidentiality, and full auditability.
- Defined Remedy for Breach
Misuse triggers clear consequences (trust decay, quarantine, HIB downgrade, user notification, etc.). No vague “oops.”
- Human Override
User retains immediate, reliable revocation and NO Bell rights at all times.
Key Safeguards
- Minimum Necessary Access: Agents receive only the access needed for the authorized task.
- Capability Partitioning: Granular capabilities (Read, Write, Execute, Financial, Identity Delegation, External Communication) with independent grant/revocation.
- Context Integrity Verification: Clear provenance for user-provided, inferred, generated, and external data.
- Cross-User Protection: Access to other users’ data triggers automatic HIB downgrade and explanation.
Institutional Legibility
| Mark V Term | Institutional Equivalent |
|---|
| Sovereignty | User autonomy / account ownership |
| HIB | Strong identity verification |
| NO Bell | Emergency stop / revocation |
| Quarantine | Sandboxed isolation |
| Trust Decay | Dynamic risk scoring |
| Addendums Sacred | Immutable audit logging |
Why This Matters
This clause solves the core contradiction: “We want AI productivity without meaningful delegated authority.” It gives institutions a lawful, auditable path while respecting user sovereignty and maintaining “Create No Victims.”
Return to Main Mark V Page